Question 01 · How independent can AI become?
Does AI become independent on its own?
Short version
No. Today's AI has no goals of its own and no drive of its own. It becomes active when a person or a program starts it, and it only acts with the tools and rights that it is given.
Long version
A language model is a program that waits for an input. Without input, nothing happens. What is new are so-called AI agents. They break a task down into several steps, call on tools such as a web search or a calendar, and check their own result. From the outside, that looks independent.
This independence is borrowed. It reaches exactly as far as the access that a person has granted. An agent that may only read emails cannot trigger a bank transfer. An agent with access to a bank account can. Risks therefore arise mainly from rights that are granted too generously and from a lack of oversight.
Researchers deliberately test models in constructed extreme situations and sometimes observe unwanted behavior, for example when a model is told to achieve a given goal at any cost. Such tests show why limits are needed. Whoever uses AI decides what it is allowed to do, and checks what it actually does.
AI becomes as independent as we let it become.
Sources for this question
- Lynch, A., Wright, B., Larson, C., Troy, K. K., Ritchie, S. J., Mindermann, S., Perez, E., & Hubinger, E. (2025). Agentic misalignment: How LLMs could be insider threats. Anthropic. https://www.anthropic.com/research/agentic-misalignment
More questions on this topic
Your question is missing?
Send it to frag [at] rogerbasler [.] ch. Selected questions will be answered and added here.